Moody's puts six U.S. regional banks on downgrade review over commercial real estate exposure
What specific factors led Moody's to consider placing the ratings of six U.S. regional banks on review for downgrade?
Moody's decision to place the ratings of six U.S. regional banks on review for downgrade was primarily driven by the banks' substantial exposure to commercial real estate (CRE) loans. These banks have a significant concentration in CRE loans, which are facing asset quality and profitability pressures due to higher-for-longer interest rates. The current economic environment has raised longstanding risks, especially during cycle downturns.
Prior to the Federal Reserve's rate-hike cycle, many regional banks chose to build and maintain substantial concentrations in CRE, which is considered a volatile asset class. With the ongoing turmoil in the commercial real estate sector, regional banks with exposure to this area have come under increased investor scrutiny.
Non-performing CRE loans as a percentage of U.S. banks' portfolios doubled to 0.81% by the end of 2023 from a year earlier, according to the International Monetary Fund's semi-annual Global Financial Stability report in April. Banks have continued to increase provisions for bad CRE loans, further highlighting the challenges faced by these institutions.
How have higher interest rates contributed to the pressures on asset quality and profitability in commercial real estate loans?
Higher interest rates have contributed to the pressures on asset quality and profitability in commercial real estate (CRE) loans in several ways. Firstly, higher interest rates increase the cost of borrowing for commercial real estate projects, making it more expensive for developers and investors to finance their projects. This can lead to a slowdown in new projects and a reduction in demand for CRE loans.
Secondly, higher interest rates can also impact the value of existing CRE loans. As interest rates rise, the cost of financing for these loans increases, which can lead to a decline in the value of the loans. This can impact the profitability of banks that hold these loans on their balance sheets.
Thirdly, higher interest rates can also impact the ability of borrowers to repay their CRE loans. As interest rates rise, borrowers may face higher debt service payments, which can impact their ability to make timely payments on their loans. This can lead to an increase in non-performing loans and negatively impact the asset quality of banks.
Lastly, higher interest rates can also impact the overall economy, which can have a ripple effect on the CRE market. If higher interest rates lead to a slowdown in economic growth, it can impact the demand for commercial real estate and lead to a decline in the value of CRE loans.
Overall, higher interest rates can have a significant impact on the asset quality and profitability of CRE loans, which can have implications for banks that hold these loans on their balance sheets.
How might a downgrade in ratings impact the operations and financial strategies of the affected regional banks?
A downgrade in ratings can have significant impacts on the operations and financial strategies of the affected regional banks. Here are some potential effects:
-
Increased Borrowing Costs: When a bank's credit rating is downgraded, it signals to investors that the bank's financial health has deteriorated. As a result, investors may demand a higher yield on the bank's bonds, which would increase the bank's borrowing costs.
-
Decreased Access to Funding: A downgrade can also decrease a bank's access to funding3. Investors may be less willing to buy the bank's bonds, and depositors may be more likely to withdraw their funds. This could force the bank to rely more heavily on more expensive forms of funding, such as wholesale borrowings.
-
Reduced Lending Capacity: If a bank's access to funding is reduced, it may have to reduce its lending. This could have a negative impact on the bank's profitability, as lending is a primary source of income for most banks.
-
Increased Regulatory Scrutiny: A downgrade could also lead to increased regulatory scrutiny. Regulators may require the bank to hold more capital, which could further reduce its lending capacity.
-
Impact on Share Price: The bank's share price may also be negatively impacted by a downgrade. This could make it more difficult for the bank to raise capital through equity issuance.
-
Potential for Further Downgrades: If a bank's financial health continues to deteriorate, it may face further downgrades. This could create a negative spiral, where the bank's borrowing costs continue to increase, its access to funding decreases, and its lending capacity is further reduced.
In response to these challenges, affected banks may need to adjust their financial strategies. They may need to increase their efforts to attract deposits, reduce their reliance on more expensive forms of funding, and take steps to improve their asset quality and profitability. They may also need to consider selling assets or raising additional capital to improve their financial position.